BigCommerce vs Shopify

Short answer: Pick BigCommerce if your catalogue or B2B pricing is too complex for a simple builder and you want it hosted without app stacking. Pick Shopify if you want a hosted store with a checkout you never maintain and an app for every specialist function.

BigCommerce

BigCommerce

Hosted ecommerce platform with deep catalogue, B2B and multi-storefront features built in rather than sold as apps.

Pick BigCommerce if your catalogue or B2B pricing is too complex for a simple builder and you want it hosted without app stacking.

vs
Shopify

Shopify

Hosted ecommerce platform with Shopify Magic and Sidekick bringing AI into product content, support and store admin.

Pick Shopify if you want a hosted store with a checkout you never maintain and an app for every specialist function.

BigCommerce vs Shopify at a glance

BigCommerceShopify
Starting price$39 per month$39 per month
Free planNoNo
Free trial15 days3 days
Pricing modelPaidPaid
PlatformsWeb, iOS, AndroidWeb, iOS, Android, Shopify
DeploymentCloudCloud
Company sizeSmall teams, Mid-size, EnterpriseSolo, Small teams, Mid-size, Enterprise
Best forMid-market and B2B merchants who want advanced features without stacking paid appsBrands of any size that want a hosted store with AI built into the admin
Our rating4 / 55 / 5

Prices are the vendor's entry paid plan on monthly billing where published; annual billing is usually cheaper. Ratings are ours and are never affected by paid placement.

Feature by feature

A tick means the vendor documents the capability. A cross means it is not in that vendor's feature list. "Not listed" means we have not captured feature data for that tool yet.

CapabilityBigCommerceShopify
Hosted storefront✓✓
Product catalogue✓✓
Checkout and payments✓✓
Multi-channel inventory✓✓
Marketplace integrations✓✓
Analytics✓✓
App ecosystem✓✓
Themes and templates✓✓
API✓✓

Pros and cons

BigCommerce

Where it is strong

  • Complex variants, customer groups and tiered pricing without apps
  • No extra transaction fee for third-party payment gateways
  • Multi-storefront runs several brands from one control panel
  • Channel Manager lists to Amazon, eBay, Walmart and Google
  • Complete GraphQL and REST APIs for headless storefronts

Where it falls short

  • Theme and app ecosystem far smaller than Shopify's
  • Self-serve plans auto-upgrade once annual sales pass a threshold
  • Admin feels dated and native AI assistance lags competitors

Shopify

Where it is strong

  • Shop Pay checkout finishes returning shoppers in a couple of taps
  • App store covers subscriptions, returns and loyalty without custom code
  • Theme editor lets non-developers rearrange sections and app blocks
  • Sidekick answers questions grounded in your own store data
  • Markets handles multi-currency pricing, duties and localised domains

Where it falls short

  • Paid apps and gateway fees push real cost well above plan price
  • Standard catalogue model strains under complex configurations and B2B pricing
  • Native recommendations, bundles and cart upsells need third-party apps
  • Built-in inventory reports cannot forecast demand or raise purchase orders

Which one should you pick?

Pick BigCommerce if

  • Your catalogue or B2B pricing is too complex for a simple builder and you want it hosted without app stacking

Pick Shopify if

  • You want a hosted store with a checkout you never maintain and an app for every specialist function
  • You are a solo buyer
  • You work in Shopify

BigCommerce starts at $39 per month. Shopify starts at $39 per month. On paper BigCommerce suits mid-market and B2B merchants who want advanced features without stacking paid apps and Shopify suits brands of any size that want a hosted store with AI built into the admin.

We have not written a hand-picked verdict for this pair yet. The tables above come from each vendor's own pricing and documentation pages, and the full reviews of BigCommerce and Shopify say where each one falls short.

Read the BigCommerce review and the Shopify review for the detail behind this page.

Integrations

Both connect to Amazon, Walmart, Instagram, TikTok.

Only BigCommerce lists eBay, Google Shopping, Facebook, PayPal, Stripe, Klaviyo.

Only Shopify lists Meta, Google, YouTube, Pinterest.

Native integrations as documented by each vendor, up to ten each. Most tools also connect through Zapier or Make.