5 Puzzle alternatives
The usual reasons to look past Puzzle: no multi-entity consolidation for holding company structures; integration catalogue is smaller than QuickBooks or Xero. Below: 5 bookkeeping tools that fix at least one of those, ranked by our rating, with the price and the fit of each.
What you get with Puzzle
Real time accounting software for startups, with automated categorisation and investor ready metrics.
- Starting price
- Not published
- Free plan
- Yes
- Deployment
- Cloud
- Best for
- Early stage startups and the bookkeepers who support them
Why people switch
- No multi-entity consolidation for holding company structures
- Integration catalogue is smaller than QuickBooks or Xero
- Few accountants have deep Puzzle experience yet
- Not suited to inventory, job costing or retail businesses
The best Puzzle alternatives
- 1Best for solo users and small teams
Digits
An AI native general ledger that categorises, reconciles and reports in near real time for startups and their accountants.
- Price
- Not published
- Free plan
- No
- Deployment
- Cloud
- Best for
- Startups that want a live view of the books, and firms serving them
- Categorisation and reconciliation run continuously, not at month end
- Interactive board reports let readers drill into any number
- Far fewer third party apps than QuickBooks or Xero
Pick Digits if you run a funded startup and want books that are always current with board reports that explain themselves.
- 2Cheapest paid plan
Xero with JAX
Xero's conversational assistant for reconciling, invoicing and asking questions about the books.
- Price
- $20 per month
- Free plan
- No
- Deployment
- Cloud
- Best for
- Small businesses working closely with an external accountant
- JAX answers questions about the books in plain language
- Reconciliation AI matches bank lines and learns from corrections
- US payroll and sales tax rely on partner apps rather than native tools
Pick Xero with JAX if you are a small business in the UK, Australia or New Zealand that works closely with an external accountant.
- 3Best mobile apps
QuickBooks with Intuit Assist
The default small business ledger, now with an AI assistant for categorisation, invoices and cash flow questions.
- Price
- from $35 per month
- Free plan
- No
- Deployment
- Cloud
- Best for
- Small businesses and the accountants who serve them
- Intuit Assist categorises bank transactions using your existing rules
- AI drafts invoice reminders and answers cash flow questions
- Single-entity ledger, so consolidation needs another tool
Pick QuickBooks with Intuit Assist if you already run on QuickBooks Online and want AI bookkeeping help without migrating.
- 4
Botkeeper
Automated bookkeeping platform sold to accounting firms, combining machine learning categorisation with human review.
- Price
- Not published
- Free plan
- No
- Deployment
- Cloud
- Best for
- Accounting firms that want to scale bookkeeping without hiring proportionally
- Categorisation accuracy improves per client as corrections accumulate
- Exception based review lets staff handle only flagged transactions
- Sold only to accounting firms, not directly to businesses
Pick Botkeeper if you run an accounting firm with twenty or more bookkeeping clients and want to grow the book without proportional hiring.
- 5
Docyt
AI bookkeeping automation for multi location businesses and the accounting firms that manage them.
- Price
- Not published
- Free plan
- No
- Deployment
- Cloud
- Best for
- Franchises, hospitality groups and firms with many entities
- Rolls up dozens of locations with location level P&L and eliminations
- Matches POS settlements, delivery payouts and tips to bank deposits
- Onboarding mappings and POS links need hands on vendor help
Pick Docyt if you operate ten or more restaurant, hotel or franchise locations and need POS reconciliation with entity level roll ups.
Puzzle and its alternatives side by side
| Tool | Starting price | Free plan | Platforms | Deployment | Company size | Rating | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Puzzle | Not published | Yes | Web | Cloud | Solo, Small teams | 4 / 5 | Early stage startups and the bookkeepers who support them |
| Digits | Not published | No | Web | Cloud | Solo, Small teams | 4 / 5 | Startups that want a live view of the books, and firms serving them |
| Xero with JAX | $20 per month | No | Web, iOS, Android | Cloud | Solo, Small teams | 4 / 5 | Small businesses working closely with an external accountant |
| QuickBooks with Intuit Assist | from $35 per month | No | Web, iOS, Android | Cloud | Solo, Small teams | 4 / 5 | Small businesses and the accountants who serve them |
| Botkeeper | Not published | No | Web | Cloud | Small teams, Mid-size | 3.5 / 5 | Accounting firms that want to scale bookkeeping without hiring proportionally |
| Docyt | Not published | No | Web, iOS, Android | Cloud | Small teams, Mid-size | 3.5 / 5 | Franchises, hospitality groups and firms with many entities |
Which alternative for which situation
You want a lower entry price
Xero with JAX ($20 per month), QuickBooks with Intuit Assist (from $35 per month) start below Puzzle on the entry paid plan. Check what the entry plan leaves out before you count the saving.
You need proper mobile apps
Xero with JAX, QuickBooks with Intuit Assist and Docyt ship both iOS and Android apps. Puzzle lists Web.
You need something Puzzle does not do
Accounting sync (QuickBooks, Xero, NetSuite) is listed by Digits, Botkeeper and Docyt. Receipt capture is listed by Xero with JAX, QuickBooks with Intuit Assist and Docyt. Mobile app is listed by Xero with JAX, QuickBooks with Intuit Assist and Docyt. See the feature matrix on each compare page for the full list.
Puzzle already has a free plan, so price is rarely the reason to leave. The gaps in the feature matrix on each compare page are the better guide.